diff --git a/src/quest_system.nvgt b/src/quest_system.nvgt
index 4575920..38ec1bb 100644
--- a/src/quest_system.nvgt
+++ b/src/quest_system.nvgt
@@ -87,29 +87,50 @@ void apply_quest_reward(int score) {
     if (favor_gain < 0) favor_gain = 0;
     favor += favor_gain;
 
-    int stones_gain = (score >= QUEST_STONE_SCORE) ? 1 : 0;
-    int logs_gain = (score >= QUEST_LOG_SCORE) ? 1 : 0;
-    int skins_gain = (score >= QUEST_SKIN_SCORE) ? 1 : 0;
-    int scrolls_gain = 0;
-    if (score >= QUEST_STONE_SCORE) scrolls_gain++;
-    if (score >= QUEST_LOG_SCORE) scrolls_gain++;
-    if (score >= QUEST_SKIN_SCORE) scrolls_gain++;
+    // Determine quantity based on score
+    // <= 2: 0
+    // 3-5: 1
+    // 6-7: 2
+    // 8-9: 3
+    // >= 10: 4
+    int quantity = 0;
+    if (score >= QUEST_LOG_SCORE) quantity = 4;
+    else if (score >= QUEST_LOG_SCORE - 2) quantity = 3;
+    else if (score >= QUEST_STONE_SCORE) quantity = 2;
+    else if (score > 2) quantity = 1;
 
-    int stones_added = add_to_stack(get_personal_count(ITEM_STONES), stones_gain);
-    add_personal_count(ITEM_STONES, stones_added);
-    int logs_added = add_to_stack(get_personal_count(ITEM_LOGS), logs_gain);
-    add_personal_count(ITEM_LOGS, logs_added);
-    int skins_added = add_to_stack(get_personal_count(ITEM_SKINS), skins_gain);
-    add_personal_count(ITEM_SKINS, skins_added);
-    int scrolls_added = add_to_stack(get_personal_count(ITEM_HEAL_SCROLL), scrolls_gain);
-    add_personal_count(ITEM_HEAL_SCROLL, scrolls_added);
+    // Select reward item
+    int[] possible_rewards = {
+        ITEM_STICKS, ITEM_VINES, ITEM_REEDS, ITEM_STONES, ITEM_LOGS, ITEM_CLAY,
+        ITEM_MEAT, ITEM_SKINS, ITEM_FEATHERS, ITEM_DOWN, ITEM_FISH, ITEM_SMOKED_FISH,
+        ITEM_HEAL_SCROLL, ITEM_INCENSE, ITEM_BASKET_FOOD
+    };
+    int reward_item = possible_rewards[random(0, possible_rewards.length() - 1)];
+    
+    int added_amount = 0;
+    if (quantity > 0) {
+        added_amount = add_to_stack(get_personal_count(reward_item), quantity);
+        add_personal_count(reward_item, added_amount);
+        
+        // Special handling for fish which needs weights
+        if (reward_item == ITEM_FISH) {
+            for (int i = 0; i < added_amount; i++) {
+                add_personal_fish_weight(get_default_fish_weight());
+            }
+        }
+    }
 
     string message = "Quest Complete!\n\nRewards:\n";
     message += get_quest_favor_phrase(score) + "\n";
-    if (stones_gain > 0) message += "Stones: +" + stones_added + "\n";
-    if (logs_gain > 0) message += "Logs: +" + logs_added + "\n";
-    if (skins_gain > 0) message += "Skins: +" + skins_added + "\n";
-    if (scrolls_gain > 0) message += "Heal Scrolls: +" + scrolls_added + "\n";
+    
+    if (added_amount > 0) {
+        message += get_item_display_name(reward_item) + ": +" + added_amount + "\n";
+    } else if (quantity > 0) {
+        message += "Inventory full, could not receive " + get_item_display_name(reward_item) + ".\n";
+    } else {
+        message += "No items awarded.\n";
+    }
+    
     message += "\nScore: " + score;
     text_reader(message, "Quest Rewards", true);
 }
@@ -140,17 +161,21 @@ void run_quest_menu() {
             speak_with_history("Closed.", true);
             break;
         }
+        
+        string count_str = " " + (selection + 1) + " of " + options.length();
 
         if (key_pressed(KEY_DOWN)) {
             selection++;
             if (selection >= options.length()) selection = 0;
-            speak_with_history(options[selection], true);
+            count_str = " " + (selection + 1) + " of " + options.length();
+            speak_with_history(options[selection] + count_str, true);
         }
 
         if (key_pressed(KEY_UP)) {
             selection--;
             if (selection < 0) selection = options.length() - 1;
-            speak_with_history(options[selection], true);
+            count_str = " " + (selection + 1) + " of " + options.length();
+            speak_with_history(options[selection] + count_str, true);
         }
 
         if (key_pressed(KEY_RETURN)) {